Posted on :
01-06-2008 at 03:14:33 AM
I purchased the Samsung F1 1TB OEM model from Newegg for $280 USD. Using HUTIL from Samsung, it reports that the Maintenance Cylinder is bad. I've RMA'd and gotten a 2nd one with the same problem.
Multiple people have reported to have 2-3 drives with this issue. Nobody has reported having a passing HUTIL test yet. Anybody here have one that passes the Self Test (does not Erase data)?
I only ran HUTIL because my first drive had issues formating that would result in BSOD but once formated, it appeared to run fine. The 2nd drive formated normally without problems but also has the error in HUTIL.
I know that it is normal for HDDs to have some surface defects and these are normally reallocated to the Maintenance Cylinder. The question is, if this drive does not have one, or at least not a functional one, what happens? Does the cluster/sector get marked as bad, data moved, and you just lose space? Or are you liable to have the OS try to write on the bad sector(s) again?
I worry because this I do plan to fill the drive with at least 700 GB of data right off the bat. Samsung hasn't gotten back to me by email & their phone support knew absolutely nothing about the product or HDDs in general. At this point, I'm 98% positive if I RMA for a replacement, it will have the same problem with the M.C. So it's either let it slide or get a Seagate - though, even discounting the speed difference, on paper, I like everything about the Samsung better.
Both drives report Reads of 90-96 MB/sec in HDTach 18.104.22.168 in both Short & Long Test though in case anybody was wondering.
Posted on :
01-22-2008 at 04:47:25 AM
When this review first came out I was all ready to buy the 1 TB Samsung. But now seeing all the many problems posted by users at Newegg has me scared. I wish the author of the article would comment on the errors that are being reported when users run Samsung's own software utility. Was this same utility run on the test sample? Thanks.
actually many of the 750GB can be had for close to $120. so 12$ cheaper doesn't make it that absurdly cheap if they were so failure prone. Not that I am challenging your failure claim but instead saying that maybe they are just not giving enough discount to match the failure rate...Hammer_Time wrote:Didnt you read my post above? No wonder the drive is so CHEAP these days, Samsung can hardly give them away cuz a lot of them are failing!!
Please stop posting "deals" on this crap drive, it has known and provable problems!!
Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD6400AAKS 640GB 7200 RPM 16MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - OEM $114.99
Fast, quiet drive
Reviewed By: DrAtomic on 5/12/2008
Rating + 5Rating + 5Rating + 5Rating + 5Rating + 5
Tech Level: high - Ownership: 1 month to 1 year
This user purchased this item from Newegg.com
Pros: Very quiet, pretty fast, and cooler than other drives. Used in an SFF so noise was a primary concern, but the speed was a pleasant surprise. Had a single platter version (320GB) and was pleased, moving to two platters is no disappointment.
Cons: Not as fast as my Raptor, but then again itâ€™s a lot quieter and much cooler.
Other Thoughts: Great drive for a desktop where noise is a concern. Would definitely buy again.
Stupify wrote:better price:
http://www.canadacomputers.com/index.ph ... HD.443.877
Western Digital Caviar (WD6400AAKS) 640GB SATAII 7200RPM 16MB Buffer (OEM) Promotional Cash Price: $104.99 reg: $106.99
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests